Note: Our theme menus focus on getting unplayed games to the table, so these lists are not meant to be the best or most well known titles in the genre, though we get a lot of those, too. Please post comments to add games that you would include in this theme!
Elysium (2-4 players)
Tzolk’in (2-4 players)
Santorini (2-4 players)
Ghost Stories (1-4 players)
Chaos in the Old World (3-4 players)
Tower of Babel (3-5 players)
Sunken City (2-4 players)
And, of course, there are several Lovecraft games that would fit into this category. We usually do Lovecraftian games as its own theme day.